An Atlas of Stories and Longing
Menu

Buffalo City Stories

Buffalo sits on the eastern shore of Lake Erie in Western New York, opposite Fort Erie, Ontario. It became a city in 1832, after it was chosen as the end of the Erie Canal. Its stories are the wings named after the city, a president sworn in at a friend’s house, a manuscript lost for a century, a millionaire borrowing from his chauffeur, and a film’s home run into the lights.

The Ansley Wilcox House on Delaware Avenue, where Theodore Roosevelt took the presidential oath in September 1901
The Ansley Wilcox House on Delaware Avenue, where Theodore Roosevelt took the presidential oath in September 1901. Photo: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Five stories

Do you know a better story for Buffalo? I’d love to hear it.

1 Buffalo wings and Teressa Bellissimo at the Anchor Bar

Stand here. The Anchor Bar, at 1047 Main Street on the corner of Main and North Streets, north of Downtown Buffalo.

The Anchor Bar’s corner building on Main Street with its signage and an American flag
The Anchor Bar at 1047 Main Street, on the corner of North Street, north of Downtown Buffalo. © Leonard J. DeFrancisci / CC BY-SA 3.0.

Buffalo wings began, by the Anchor Bar’s account, on 4 March 1964, when Dominic Bellissimo, tending bar, asked his mother, Teressa, to make his friends something to eat. Wings were the cheap part that usually went into the stock pot, but Teressa deep-fried them and tossed them in cayenne hot sauce. The family has told it other ways, and a rival, John Young, said he served wings first. In 1977, the part nobody wanted got its own day, when the city declared 29 July 1977 Chicken Wing Day.

2 Theodore Roosevelt sworn in at a friend’s house on Delaware Avenue

Stand here. The Ansley Wilcox House, 641 Delaware Avenue, now the Theodore Roosevelt Inaugural National Historic Site, shown by guided tour.

A large columned Greek Revival house on a tree-lined avenue in an old halftone photograph
The Ansley Wilcox House on Delaware Avenue, Buffalo, as pictured in Leslie’s Weekly after Roosevelt’s inauguration. Robert Lee Dunn / Public domain.

Theodore Roosevelt became the youngest president ever in the library of his friend Ansley Wilcox. When President McKinley was shot at the Pan-American Exposition in September 1901, Roosevelt rushed to Buffalo. Assured McKinley would recover, he went camping in the Adirondacks, until a guide brought word that the President had suddenly worsened. He reached a station just before dawn and took trains back. McKinley died on 14 September, and Roosevelt took the oath in borrowed clothes, clutching nervously at the lapel of his frock coat.

See also Theodore Roosevelt’s speech with a bullet in his chest, in Milwaukee; Roosevelt’s Rough Riders and the Tampa Bay Hotel’s rocking chairs.

3 The lost half of Huckleberry Finn at the Central Library

Stand here. The Mark Twain Room in the Central Library, where the manuscript lies under glass, two pages at a time.

A library room with a glass display case at centre, a fireplace behind and portraits of Mark Twain
The Mark Twain Room in Buffalo’s Central Library, with the Huckleberry Finn manuscript in its glass case. © Andre Carrotflower / CC BY-SA 4.0.

Mark Twain’s manuscript of Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is in Buffalo because the library’s curator, James Fraser Gluck, wrote and asked for it. The first half, 665 leaves, was still with Gluck when he died suddenly, and it was lost. Twain thought the printer had probably destroyed it. In 1990, it turned up in a steamer trunk in a Hollywood attic belonging to one of Gluck’s granddaughters. In 1992, the two halves were reunited in Buffalo, 105 years after they had last been together.

See also Emperor Norton, the San Francisco bankrupt who crowned himself.

4 Darwin Martin’s Frank Lloyd Wright house on Jewett Parkway

Stand here. Frank Lloyd Wright’s Martin House, 125 Jewett Parkway, open to visitors and restored by 2019, with its lost pergola, conservatory, and carriage house rebuilt.

A long, low Prairie-style house with broad overhanging roofs set behind a lawn
Frank Lloyd Wright’s Darwin D. Martin House on Jewett Parkway, in Buffalo’s Parkside district. Dave Pape / Public domain.

For some fifty years, Frank Lloyd Wright called the Martin House his “opus”. He designed it for Darwin Martin, who had joined the Larkin Company as a 13-year-old soap salesman and risen to be a senior executive. Martin went on backing Wright with commissions and money. In 1929, Martin was worth $2.5 million, but five years later he was borrowing from his chauffeur. When Martin died in the house the next year, Wright still owed him $70,000.

See also Frank Lloyd Wright and the Arizona Biltmore’s real architect, in Phoenix.

5 Robert Redford’s home run into the Rockpile’s lights

Stand here. Site of the demolished War Memorial Stadium, the Rockpile, on the East Side. A sports pavilion there keeps the stadium’s original entrances.

A large stadium entrance gateway at dusk on a city street corner
The surviving entrance gate of War Memorial Stadium, the Rockpile, at Best Street and Jefferson Avenue, Buffalo. © Andre Carrotflower / CC BY-SA 4.0.

The ending of The Natural (1984), with Robert Redford’s Roy Hobbs smashing a home run into the lights, was found here. Barry Levinson’s crew wanted a stadium that could pass for the early 20th century, and the Rockpile, nicknamed for its poor upkeep, needed little dressing. They still had no ending, until they looked up at its lights and had their “Eureka” moment. The effects man rigged the bulbs to explode, and when Hobbs’s ball hit, they rained down a glass-like shower.

Books to read before you visit Buffalo

Films to watch before you visit Buffalo

Questions

Who invented Buffalo wings?

The Anchor Bar credits Teressa Bellissimo, who in 1964 deep-fried chicken wings and tossed them in cayenne hot sauce. The family’s own versions differ, from a snack for her son’s friends to wings at Friday midnight for Catholic customers or a delivery sent by mistake. A rival, John Young, said he served wings first, in his tomato-based Mumbo sauce.

Can you visit the house where Theodore Roosevelt was sworn in?

Yes. The Ansley Wilcox House at 641 Delaware Avenue is now the Theodore Roosevelt Inaugural National Historic Site. Visits are by guided tour only, and the library where he took the oath is furnished with original and period pieces.

Where was President McKinley shot, and can you see the spot?

He was shot on 6 September 1901 inside the Temple of Music, a concert hall built for the Pan-American Exposition. The hall was demolished when the fair ended, and the grounds between Delaware and Elmwood Avenues became housing. A granite boulder and marker on a traffic island on Fordham Drive mark the approximate site.

Sources

  1. “Buffalo, New York”, Wikipedia.
  2. “Buffalo wing”, Wikipedia.
  3. “Anchor Bar”, Wikipedia.
  4. Anchor Bar, “History”.
  5. “First inauguration of Theodore Roosevelt”, Wikipedia.
  6. Theodore Roosevelt Inaugural Site Foundation, “The Inauguration”.
  7. Theodore Roosevelt Inaugural Site Foundation, “FAQ”.
  8. National Park Service, “Foundation Document Overview, Theodore Roosevelt Inaugural National Historic Site”.
  9. National Park Service, “History & Culture”, Theodore Roosevelt Inaugural National Historic Site.
  10. “Theodore Roosevelt Inaugural National Historic Site”, Wikipedia.
  11. “Assassination of William McKinley”, Wikipedia.
  12. “Temple of Music”, Wikipedia.
  13. Buffalo & Erie County Public Library, “Huckleberry Finn manuscript history”.
  14. Buffalo & Erie County Public Library digital collections, “Adventures of Huckleberry Finn [manuscript]”, catalogue record.
  15. “Bill Loos and the long-lost Huck Finn manuscript”, Traveling with Twain, Northwestern University Medill.
  16. Visit Buffalo Niagara, “How Downtown Buffalo Became the Home of an American Literary Masterpiece”.
  17. “Darwin D. Martin House”, Wikipedia.
  18. Martin House Restoration Corporation, “Frank Lloyd Wright’s Martin House”.
  19. Martin House Restoration Corporation, “Timeline”.
  20. “The Natural (film)”, Wikipedia.
  21. “War Memorial Stadium (Buffalo, New York)”, Wikipedia.
  22. “‘The Natural’ at 35: Here’s how Robert Redford hit that explosive home run”, Yahoo Entertainment.
  23. “Buffalo’s best on the big screen”, The Spectrum (University at Buffalo).
  24. “Buffalo ’66”, Wikipedia.
  25. “City of Light (novel)”, Wikipedia.
  26. “Bruce Almighty”, Wikipedia.
  27. “Death of a President”, Washington Examiner.
  28. “Moon Over Buffalo”, Wikipedia.
  29. “File:WilcoxMansion.jpg”, Wikimedia Commons (the photo).

More places nearby