I had clients in Edinburgh for a while, and can recommend The Scotsman if you are looking for somewhere nice to stay. Conan Doyle (Sherlock) and J. K. Rowling (Harry Potter) both did great work here. Also… Rockstar North, makers of Grand Theft Auto, is based here. Quite a collection of things I love.
— Nick
Edinburgh’s medieval Old Town and Georgian New Town became a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1995. The city is the capital of Scotland, on the southern shore of the Firth of Forth. A queen’s secretary murdered at supper and a councillor who burgled by night come ahead of a dog at his master’s grave, the doctor behind Sherlock Holmes, and a station that named a novel.
1 The murder of Mary, Queen of Scots’ secretary at Holyroodhouse
Stand here. The Palace of Holyroodhouse, the monarch’s official residence in Scotland. Mary’s 16th-century rooms are open except when the royal family is there.
Mary, Queen of Scots, was six months pregnant with the future James VI when she was at supper in her rooms at Holyroodhouse on 9 March 1566. With her was David Rizzio, her Italian private secretary and a fine singer. Her husband, Lord Darnley, said to be jealous because of rumours that Rizzio was the father, had joined a plot to kill him. Rizzio hid behind the queen, but he was seized, dragged through her bedchamber, and stabbed more than fifty times. The murder began Darnley’s own downfall.
2 Deacon Brodie, the Edinburgh councillor who burgled by night
Stand here. The pub named after him stands at the corner of the Lawnmarket and Bank Street, on the Royal Mile. Brodie’s Close keeps his name too.
By day, William Brodie was a cabinet-maker and councillor, by night a burglar, and his double life helped inspire Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde. He copied clients’ keys in wax, and stole to pay for gambling and five children by two mistresses who didn’t know of each other. In 1788, an armed raid on the Excise Office got his gang only £16, and he was hanged before a crowd of 40,000. One tale says he wore a steel collar to cheat the noose. If so, it failed.
3 Greyfriars Bobby and his master’s grave in Greyfriars Kirkyard
Stand here. The corner of George IV Bridge and Candlemaker Row. Bobby’s statue tops a fountain there, Edinburgh’s smallest listed building.
In 1961, Disney filmed Greyfriars Bobby: The True Story of a Dog. John Gray, a police nightwatchman, was buried in Greyfriars Kirkyard, and his terrier, Bobby, is said to have guarded the grave for fourteen years. But the historian Jan Bondeson argues that the cemetery’s curator and a restaurant owner made the story up to bring in custom, feeding a stray to keep it in the graveyard. When that dog died in 1867, Bondeson says, they swapped in a pure-bred Skye terrier. Tourists still rub the statue’s nose for luck.
4 Dr Joseph Bell, the Edinburgh teacher behind Sherlock Holmes
Stand here. Picardy Place. The house where Arthur Conan Doyle was born was demolished around 1970, and a life-size bronze of Sherlock Holmes stands nearby.
The bronze statue of Sherlock Holmes at Picardy Place, near the site of Arthur Conan Doyle’s birthplace.August Dominus / CC0.
Sherlock Holmes, his creator wrote, began with Edinburgh’s Dr Joseph Bell. A medical student, Arthur Conan Doyle, became Bell’s outpatient clerk. Bell, Doyle recalled, could diagnose people before they opened their mouths. From red clay on one woman’s shoes, he worked out that she had been to the Botanic Garden. Doyle’s medical practice failed, and while he waited for patients, he returned to fiction. His detective appeared in A Study in Scarlet in 1887. Doyle wrote to Bell, “It is most certainly to you that I owe Sherlock Holmes.”
The title of Trainspotting, Irvine Welsh’s first novel, published in 1993, comes from this station. In the 1980s, the derelict building was notorious as a haven for drug addicts. In the novel, Renton and Begbie are using it as a toilet when an old drunk asks if they’re “trainspottin’”. He turns out to be Begbie’s estranged father. Where the platforms were, there is now a children’s soft-play centre.
Pack nothing. Leave Friday.
Every Friday, I write a free letter, Journey, that takes us on a trip through places, stories, and ideas.
The Heart of Midlothian(Walter Scott, 1818). A novel named after the Old Tolbooth, the High Street prison where Deacon Brodie was hanged.
The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie(Muriel Spark, 1961). A novel about a teacher in 1930s Edinburgh, based partly on Spark’s own teacher at James Gillespie’s School for Girls.
Knots and Crosses(Ian Rankin, 1987). A novel. Rankin put Rebus on Arden Street in Marchmont, opposite the window he looked out of while writing it.
One Day(David Nicholls, 2009). A novel. Dexter and Emma spend the night together after graduating from the University of Edinburgh, on 15 July 1988, and climb Arthur’s Seat.
Greyfriars Bobby(Eleanor Atkinson, 1912). A novel of the dog’s story, with John Traill, owner of Ye Olde Greyfriars Dining-Rooms, among its characters.
One Good Turn(Kate Atkinson, 2006). A crime novel set in Edinburgh during the Festival, with a drowned woman on Cramond Island.
Films to watch before you visit Edinburgh
Trainspotting(Danny Boyle, 1996). A film. Its opening chase, Renton and Spud fleeing security after shoplifting, was shot on Princes Street and Calton Road, under Regent Bridge.
Avengers: Infinity War(Anthony and Joe Russo, 2018). A film. The Scarlet Witch and Vision are ambushed by Thanos’s thugs on the Waverley station concourse, near platform 2.
Questions
Can you see where David Rizzio was murdered at Holyrood Palace?
Yes, when the palace is open. Mary, Queen of Scots’ 16th-century apartments in James V’s Tower are open through the year, except when the royal family is in residence. A small plaque in the outer chamber marks the spot. The red “bloodstain” beneath it is now widely put down to Victorian dramatic licence.
Is the story of Greyfriars Bobby true?
Partly, and it is disputed. Bobby was real, and in 1867 the Lord Provost paid his licence and gave him a collar, now in the Museum of Edinburgh. But the historian Jan Bondeson argues that the first Bobby was a stray, and that when he died in 1867 he was replaced by a Skye terrier, which lived until 1872.
Is Edinburgh the capital of Scotland?
Yes. Edinburgh is Scotland’s capital city, in the south-east of the country, on the southern shore of the Firth of Forth. Its castle stands on a rocky crag, the remnant of an extinct volcano, and the Palace of Holyroodhouse is the monarch’s official residence in Scotland.