An Atlas of Stories and Longing
Menu

Phoenix City Stories

I don’t know much about Phoenix other than it’s the setting for Marion’s second biggest mistake in the Hitchcock classic, Psycho. John McCain also gave his concession speech there in 2008. Whatever our differences, I hope that we can all see that speech as the words of a class act. More of that, please.

— Nick

Settled in 1867 as a farming community near where the Salt and Gila rivers meet, Phoenix is now the capital of Arizona, in the Salt River Valley in the Sonoran Desert. Besides the canal that founded the town, the stories cover the confession behind the Miranda warning, a governor and the Phoenix Lights, a castle built for a daughter, and a hotel Frank Lloyd Wright claimed.

The Arizona Biltmore, designed by Albert McArthur, which opened in 1929 near 24th Street and Camelback Road
The Arizona Biltmore, designed by Albert McArthur, which opened in 1929 near 24th Street and Camelback Road. Tony the Marine, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Five stories

Do you know a better story for Phoenix? I’d love to hear it.

1 Ernesto Miranda and the right to remain silent

Stand here. Historic Phoenix City Hall, at 2nd Avenue and Jefferson Street. The police museum on its ground floor shows his booking photo and confession.

The ornate Spanish Colonial Revival facade of Phoenix’s old city hall building
Historic Phoenix City Hall, part of the 1928 County-City Administration Building on 2nd Avenue in downtown Phoenix. © Visitor7 / CC BY-SA 3.0.

The words “You have the right to remain silent” come from a Phoenix arrest. In 1963, police questioned Ernesto Miranda over a kidnapping and rape, and he signed a confession without being told he could stay silent or ask for a lawyer. The Supreme Court threw out his conviction and made police say those words first. Miranda was convicted again without the confession. On parole, he sold signed Miranda cards for $1.50. When he was stabbed to death in a downtown bar, several were found on him.

2 The governor who joked about the Phoenix Lights

Stand here. Piestewa Peak, once called Squaw Peak, anywhere you can see it. Arizona’s governor said the craft he saw passed silently over it.

A rugged desert peak rising above the low hills of the Phoenix Mountains
Piestewa Peak in the Phoenix Mountains, seen from the Wrigley Mansion. © Ted Eytan / CC BY-SA 2.0.

Shortly after the Phoenix Lights appeared on 13 March 1997, the governor, Fife Symington, called a press conference and joked that they had found who was responsible. Out came his chief of staff in an alien costume with an oversized head and eyes. Military jets and flares have been blamed. But ten years later, Symington said he had seen a craft himself, moving silently over Piestewa Peak. He had stayed quiet to avoid panic. “In your gut,” he said, “you could just tell it was otherworldly.”

3 Jack Swilling’s canal and how Phoenix got its name

Stand here. S’edav Va’aki Museum, formerly Pueblo Grande, 4619 East Washington Street. Its site keeps a platform mound and, in the Park of Four Waters, Hohokam canal remains.

The eroded earthen walls of a large Hohokam platform mound at a desert archaeological site
The Hohokam platform mound at S’edav Va’aki Museum, formerly Pueblo Grande, on East Washington Street in Phoenix. © Visitor7 / CC BY-SA 3.0.

Phoenix is named after the mythical bird reborn from its ashes. Jack Swilling noticed the mounds of old canals, dug by the Hohokam people and abandoned centuries before. In 1867, he formed a company and dug a canal to bring in river water. An Englishman named the new town for a city born from the ruins of another. But Swilling came to depend on morphine and drink. In 1878, arrested for a stagecoach robbery, he died in Yuma.

4 Mystery Castle, built by a father for his daughter

Stand here. Mystery Castle, in the foothills of South Mountain Park.

The side of a rambling house of rough stone and adobe set in the desert
Mystery Castle, the rambling stone house Boyce Gulley built in the foothills of South Mountain Park, Phoenix. ksblack99 / Public domain.

In 1948, Life magazine photographed Mary Lou Gulley on the roof stairs of her castle under the headline “Life Visits a Mystery Castle”. Her father, Boyce, had built it after learning he had tuberculosis and moving from Seattle, out of stone, adobe, car parts, and old mine rails. When he died, a lawyer told Mary Lou and her mother that they had inherited it. They moved in, to eighteen rooms, a chapel, and a dungeon, with no electricity until 1992. Mary Lou showed visitors round until her death in 2010.

5 Frank Lloyd Wright and the Arizona Biltmore’s real architect

Stand here. The Arizona Biltmore, near 24th Street and Camelback Road, is still a resort, built of what are now called Biltmore Blocks.

A close view of a wall built from geometric patterned concrete blocks
Patterned “Biltmore Blocks” cast for Albert McArthur’s Arizona Biltmore, near 24th Street and Camelback Road, Phoenix. © Marine 69-71 / CC BY-SA 4.0.

Frank Lloyd Wright spent four months advising on the building of the Arizona Biltmore, but its architect was Albert McArthur, who had once worked with Wright. McArthur built it for his brothers from Wright’s textile blocks, geometric blocks cast on site from desert sand. Then he turned the square blocks into rectangles. Wright condemned the result and claimed the design in public, though in a letter he wrote, “Albert McArthur is the architect of that building.” The hotel opened in 1929, and it is still often called Wright’s.

Books to read before you visit Phoenix

Films to watch before you visit Phoenix

Questions

Where can you see Ernesto Miranda’s confession?

At the Phoenix Police Museum, on the ground floor of Historic Phoenix City Hall at 2nd Avenue and Jefferson Street. The building was home to the Phoenix Police Department until 1975, and the museum’s Miranda exhibit shows his police report, booking photo, and confession.

What were the Phoenix Lights?

Lights seen over Arizona and Nevada on 13 March 1997, in two events. A moving formation at about 8 p.m., often seen as a huge triangle, has been put down to five A-10 jets. Stationary lights over Phoenix at about 10 p.m. have been put down to flares dropped by other A-10s in an exercise.

Is Phoenix the capital of Arizona?

Yes. Phoenix is Arizona’s capital and its most populous city, and the fifth-most populous city in the United States. The territorial capital moved there from Prescott in 1889, and Phoenix became a state capital when Arizona joined the Union as the 48th state on 14 February 1912.

Sources

More places nearby