An Atlas of Stories and Longing
Menu

San Juan City Stories

San Juan, the capital of Puerto Rico, faces the Atlantic on the island’s north-east coast. The Spanish founded it in 1521, and the original city, Old San Juan, stands on a small island ringed by walls. Its stories here are the house Ponce de León never lived in, an English earl taking El Morro, a fight over the piña colada, the bar behind The Rum Diary, and Despacito’s barrio.

Castillo San Felipe del Morro, begun in 1539, in Old San Juan
Castillo San Felipe del Morro, begun in 1539, in Old San Juan. Thank You (23 Millions+) views, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Five stories

Do you know a better story for San Juan? I’d love to hear it.

1 Ponce de León and the Casa Blanca he never lived in

Stand here. Casa Blanca, in Old San Juan, now a house museum run by the Institute of Puerto Rican Culture. His tomb is in the cathedral nearby.

A white two-storey house with wooden balconies above an old stone wall, framed by trees
Casa Blanca, the house built for Juan Ponce de León’s family, seen from Calle de las Monjas in Old San Juan. © Ligocsicnarf89 / CC BY 4.0.

Juan Ponce de León named Florida, and legend has him searching there for the Fountain of Youth, a myth most historians say grew up after his death. He was Puerto Rico’s first governor, and in 1521 building began on a house for his family in the new city on this islet. That year he led settlers to Florida, where the Calusa attacked and an arrow struck his thigh. He sailed to Havana and died of the wound. His descendants lived in the house until the 1700s. He never did.

2 The Earl of Cumberland takes El Morro by land

Stand here. Castillo San Felipe del Morro, in Old San Juan, begun in 1539, part of a UNESCO World Heritage Site and open to visitors.

Aerial view of a stone fortress on a rocky headland, with green lawns and a city stretching behind
Castillo San Felipe del Morro from the air, with the open esplanade between the fort and Old San Juan behind it. © Nils Huenerfuerst / CC BY 4.0.

Sir Francis Drake attacked San Juan with his fleet in 1595 and failed. Three years later, George Clifford, Earl of Cumberland, a courtier of Elizabeth I who had run through much of his fortune, sailed to rebuild it by raiding Spain. El Morro was built against attack from the sea. Cumberland came over land, with 1,700 men against 350 defenders, and took it. Then dysentery ran through his army, and within months they had gone. What he won raiding Spain, he lost in jousting and horse racing.

3 San Juan’s fight over who made the piña colada

Stand here. The Caribe Hilton’s bar, beside the 18th-century San Gerónimo fort, where its bartender’s recipe is on the wall beside his photo.

Postcard aerial view of a white high-rise hotel with pools and palms, a small stone fort on the shore at left
The Caribe Hilton hotel in San Juan, with the Fortín de San Gerónimo at left, on a 1960s postcard. Rahola Photo Supply / Public domain.

The Caribe Hilton says the piña colada was born at its bar in 1954. Its bartender, Ramón “Monchito” Marrero, spent three months blending rum, coconut cream, and pineapple juice until he felt it captured the flavours of Puerto Rico. But a colleague at the hotel claims to have made it in 1953, and in Old San Juan a stone plaque outside Barrachina restaurant says a different Ramón created it there in 1963. The travel guide Frommer’s thinks the evidence favours the Hilton. Barrachina’s plaque still says otherwise.

4 Hunter S. Thompson’s Rum Diary bar in Old San Juan

Stand here. El Patio de Sam, on the Plaza de San José in Old San Juan, a favourite hangout of Thompson’s, still serving Puerto Rican food.

A sunny square with a bronze statue on a white pedestal, a large tree and pastel colonial houses
Plaza de San José in Old San Juan, the square of El Patio de Sam, with its 1882 statue of Ponce de León. © Ligocsicnarf89 / CC BY 4.0.

Long before Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, Hunter S. Thompson moved to San Juan in 1960 to work for a bowling magazine, which folded soon after he arrived. The English-language San Juan Star’s managing editor, William Kennedy, turned him down. So Thompson freelanced, befriended the Star’s writers, and drew on their world for a novel, The Rum Diary, with this bar, renamed Al’s Backyard, as his reporter’s local. It waited until 1998 to be published. By then, the editor who turned him away had won a Pulitzer Prize.

See also Hunter S. Thompson’s Fear and Loathing at Circus Circus, in Las Vegas.

5 Despacito and La Perla, the barrio outside the walls

Stand here. La Perla, a seafront barrio, or neighbourhood, of brightly coloured houses between the north wall of Old San Juan and the Atlantic.

Colourful houses along a rocky Atlantic shore below an old city wall, with a fortress on the headland beyond
La Perla’s houses between Old San Juan’s north wall and the Atlantic, seen from Castillo San Cristóbal. © G. Edward Johnson / CC BY 4.0.

In December 2016, Luis Fonsi and Daddy Yankee filmed the video for Despacito here, in a barrio with a bad reputation that began as the site of a slaughterhouse. It became the most-viewed video on YouTube, and tourists from all over the world came down these streets. “There is no monster here, no bogeyman,” said Yashira Gómez of the community board, and private donors paid $80,000 to paint 402 houses. Then, in September 2017, Hurricane Maria hit, and La Perla “looked like it was hit by a bomb”.

Books to read before you visit San Juan

Films to watch before you visit San Juan

Questions

Can you visit El Morro?

Yes. Castillo San Felipe del Morro, begun in 1539, is part of San Juan National Historic Site, run by the US National Park Service, and has been a UNESCO World Heritage Site since 1983. Over two million people a year explore it.

Where is Ponce de León buried?

In the Cathedral of San Juan Bautista, in Old San Juan. He died in Havana in 1521, after an arrow wound in Florida. His remains lay in the crypt of San José Church from 1559 until 1836, when they were moved to the cathedral.

Is San Juan part of the United States?

San Juan is the capital of Puerto Rico, an unincorporated territory of the United States. Puerto Ricans have been US citizens since 1917, the currency is the US dollar, and Spanish and English are both official languages, though Spanish predominates.

Sources

More places nearby